My parents (one who has Mastercard and one who has Visa) called today and tried to use their credit cards for the order. Neither of them worked, so we asked for the order to be shipped to the store. American Eagle told us they don't ship to stores, and basically left us with nothing saying they'd tell their technician. I'm going to use my boyfriend's Paypal (as he is awesome) on a new order. Still, they haven't told us if anyone else is having a problem, if this problem just exists with Canadian credit cards, or if something else is going on.
:( And now I can't get the free lipstick I would have gotten as they've run out.